• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

The Beard And The Baker

Midwest Food, Family, + Fun

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Recipes
    • Appetizers
    • Breakfast
    • Desserts
    • Dinner Time
    • Drinks
    • Side Dishes
  • Lifestyle
    • Eating & Drinking
    • Family Friendly
    • Shopping
  • Family Travel
    • East Coast
    • West Coast
    • Midwest
    • The South
  • Privacy Policy
  • Press
Home » Sexton’s Pizza Review | Hilliard, OH

Sexton’s Pizza Review | Hilliard, OH

March 29, 2022 by Hannah Lewis Leave a Comment

38 shares
  • Share
  • Tweet

Sexton’s Pizza is a made from scratch pizza shop that is family friendly and absolutely delicious! They have three locations in Columbus, Ohio that you can dine-in or grab pizza (and more!) for carryout. 

Fresh cut fries on serving plate with fried and breaded mozzarella sticks in the background, at Sexton's Pizza in Hilliard, Ohio.
Deep dish build your own pizza with half pepperoni and half cheese at Sexton's Pizza in Hilliard, Ohio.
Dining area seating with mural on back wall at Sexton's Pizza in Hilliard, Ohio.

Everything you need to know about Sexton’s Pizza in Columbus, Ohio.

A family friendly spot with amazing food? Sign us up! Sexton’s Pizza is a pizza shop in Columbus that is worth any hype it gets and should be a must visit for pizza lovers. Here are all the details you need to know before visiting. 

  • They have three locations in Columbus. We visited the Hilliard location which is about a 1/2 mile walk from the Center Street Market. The location is in a mini business park but has signage to designate its location! Here are addresses for all three locations.
  • There are four options for pizza crusts! You can get Hand Tossed, Sicilian (+$2), Motown Deep Dish, or Cauliflower Crust. We got the Motown Deep Dish and it was delightful.
  • You can build your own pizza or choose from a speciality option. I usually choose build my own but they have some amazing speciality pizzas that we tried one of those (scroll down to see which one!).
  • They have a pretty awesome cocktail selection, nice sized bar, and outdoor patio that I bet will be pretty amazing during the summer season. The Hilliard location also has a little area for live music! Watch their Facebook page for details.
  • They are CLOSED on Mondays. Plan your visit accordingly.
Mother and son posing in front of pizza mural at Sexton's Pizza in Hilliard, Ohio.
Child enjoying apple juice while seated at Sexton's Pizza in Hilliard, Ohio.

Pizza Pricing At Sexton’s Pizza Locations

The prices at Sexton’s Pizza are specific to menu item and location which you can view here on their website. For reference, we got two sodas, a Motown Crust Specialty Pizza, fries, mozzarella sticks, and a Motown build your own pizza and our total (with tip) was $80. I thought it was totally worth the price. I’m not sure if they have any pizza coupons but it’s worth it to keep an eye out for them!

More specifically, we got the Bee Bee Q (garlic sauce base, fried chicken, onion, with a hot honey bbq and ranch drizzle) and it was incredible. It was fluffy but crispy with a perfect balance of flavors. 10/10 would get again.

The fries though were PERFECT. We are always looking for fresh cut “fair fries” as we call them and Sexton’s Pizza delivers. Don’t forget to get a side of their house made ranch – it rivals Jet’s Pizza and that’s saying something.

Bee Bee Q Detroit Style Pizza with garlic sauce, fried chicken, onion, hot honey, bbq sauce, and a ranch drizzle at Sexton's Pizza in Hilliard, Ohio.
Cheese pull of deep dish pizza at Sexton's Pizza in Hilliard, Ohio.

Do We Recommend Sexton’s Pizza

We definitely recommend giving Sexton’s Pizza a try ASAP at their newly opened Hilliard location or their others in Reynoldsburg or Gahanna. You can order online here. To see more details in video form, give us a follow on TikTok and Instagram!

Other Family Friendly Columbus Restaurants

Here are a few other Columbus restaurants that we love and are family approved.

  • Rusty Bucket Restaurant & Tavern
  • OH Pizza & Brew
  • The Pearl in Dublin (especially for brunch!)
Pepperoni and cheese Detroit style pizza shown on pan at Sexton's Pizza in Hilliard, Ohio.

Share this:

  • Pinterest

Filed Under: Eating & Drinking

Previous Post: « Incredible Sunday Brunch at The Barn at Rocky Fork Creek
Next Post: The Children’s Museum of Indianapolis – A Must Visit for Families »

Reader Interactions

We'd Love To Hear Your Thoughts on This Recipe!Cancel reply

Primary Sidebar

a little bit organic, a little bit golden arches. love local but love Target. 👶🏻👧🏻👨🏻👩🏻 sharing food, family, and fun in columbus, ohio and beyond.

Affiliate Link Disclosure

The Beard and The Baker is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Blog posts and recipes may contain affiliate links.

Copyright © 2025 · Foodie Pro & The Genesis Framework

38 shares